Globe

Universities under threat from MOOC revolution

February 07, 2014

By RYUICHI KANARI/ The Asahi Shimbun Staff Writer

It’s been called the biggest educational revolution in centuries, an increasingly popular movement that could shape the future of higher learning around the globe.

And it could also threaten the very raison d’etre of universities.

The revolution goes by the name of MOOC, or Massive Open Online Courses, and almost 10 million students have already signed up worldwide. Centered in the United States, it involves educational services that distribute university courses for free over the Internet.

Students can watch any number of top-notch lectures for free, and they are also given homework and tests. They can discuss matters and queries with other students, too.

Furthermore, once a certain level is attained, they will receive a “completion certificate.” Although it is not an officially recognized accreditation, students use the certificate as proof of study when looking for work.

The revolution began two years ago when a prestigious U.S. university began releasing some of its classes into the public domain. The main bodies behind the MOOC boom are two venture companies, Coursera and Udacity, and edX, a not-for-profit institution. Though all three are based in the United States, universities across Europe, Asia and South America are also jumping on board.

Budding students can now take their pick from around 1,200 courses offered by more than 200 university educators around the world, according to Dhawal Shah, a founder of Class Central, a website offering free online courses for MOOC. The only thing required is an Internet connection.

Traditionally, higher education was locked behind a “wall” of tough entrance examinations and high tuition fees, but these walls are being torn down.

That’s why some say the MOOCs revolution signals the biggest shake-up in education since the 15th century, when the Gutenberg printing press heralded the mass dissemination of knowledge.

The revolution is also changing the way students study. The transformation can be seen in Tokyo with the increasing number of commuting office workers studying on tablet computers.

Osamu Takahashi, 37, is a member of this new tribe in Japan’s capital. On weekday train journeys, he listens to business lectures from the Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania. On weekends, he studies bookkeeping and accounting.

“It’s like I finally got the chance to study overseas,” he says.

Online courses can be a lonely business, so study groups are springing up across the United States. These give students a chance to meet up on weekends and help each other with homework. The location might be a café, for instance, but the conversations are the same as those among regular university students.

New York office worker Varun Nagpal, 29, is a big fan of this way of learning. “With MOOCs, we don’t have to pay high tuition and enroll in university to learn.”

He says his weekends have totally changed since he started the course. More than 5,000 such study groups have been set up around the world, including in Tokyo.

One hot topic of conversation in MOOC circles is a boy genius from Mongolia. When he was 15, he enrolled in a course offered by the prestigious Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) and astounded lecturers by attaining a perfect score. Friends, family and his high school principal urged him to take the MIT entrance exam. He has since received a scholarship and moved to the real campus last autumn.

So why are universities and companies offering fee-based education for free? The answer lies with big data. When these institutions attract students from around the world, they are also gathering information about the students’ educational backgrounds.

This data is used for two main purposes. The information provides a statistical insight into how students with top grades study, in other words, “how geniuses learn.” The information can be used to find effective education methods and improve teaching materials.

The second purpose is to make money. Information about student interests and results can be packaged and sold to partner companies with the consent of students. Udacity has devised a framework for introducing potential employees, a service that costs “a fraction” of the $20,000 per employee a headhunter would charge, according to Udacity’s founder, Sebastian Thrun.

MOOCs originally found favor “outside” the university system by, for example, catering to those who couldn’t attend university.

Now, though, their influence is starting to be felt “inside” the system, too.

Some U.S. universities are experimenting with the classroom use of MOOC videos from other elite universities. Students watch or listen to lectures at home and then participate in dialogue-based lessons at the university, where they study in groups and debate with fellow students. Previously, universities often used textbooks written by distinguished professors. Viewed in this context, MOOCs are simply “21st century textbooks.”

There is considerable opposition, though. When San Jose State University proposed using MOOC lectures by Harvard University professor Michael Sandel, teachers in the philosophy department were not happy. They responded with an open letter that said the move toward MOOCs was motivated by cost-cutting and was a “great peril to our university.”

Critics also say that “the diversity of education will be destroyed” by using a single professor’s course to teach tens of thousands of students.

As one article in the Chronicle of Higher Education put it, “MOOCs are now at the forefront of the McDonaldization of higher education.”

The revolution has only just begun, and it’s anyone’s guess how far it will develop. Nonetheless, in the United States, where soaring school fees are becoming a social problem, MOOC fever is catching on.

In Washington last December, the President’s Council of Advisors on Science and Technology made a proposal to President Barack Obama. To accelerate the development of MOOCs, the committee pressed for accrediting standards to be relaxed to allow more online courses to receive formal accreditation.

If the proposal is approved, students will find it easier to take online courses not affiliated to their university. Traditionally, students could only learn from their university professors. Eventually, though, most courses possibly face competition from outside the university.

Eric Rabkin, the 67-year-old associate provost for online education at the State University of New York at Stony Brook, compares the situation to the music industry.

In the past, he says, the music industry used to package songs together as albums, but new distribution platforms allow consumers to buy individual songs, so publishers have lost power. Likewise, new services allow professors to sell courses individually online.

“We all need to prepare for big changes,” he warns.

STUDENTS USING MOOCS TO LAND JOBS

Firms providing MOOCs are keeping a sharp eye on the performance of students across the globe because money can be made from finding the best students and introducing them to partner companies.

For Tamir Duberstein, a 25-year-old Canadian, MOOCs became a stepping stone to a new career. Now a programmer at a popular high-tech firm in San Francisco, Duberstein used to work as a mechanical engineer in Canada. This job gave him no satisfaction, so he jumped at the chance when a friend introduced him to MOOCs.

He was interested in programming, so he studied courses such as “Introduction to Computer Science” or “Web Development” after arriving home from work.

Duberstein watched the videos, solved the practice questions and had a go at coding himself.

He took six courses and studied hard. One day, a letter arrived from a recruitment officer at Udacity, a MOOC distributor.

“Dear Tamir,” it began, “if you are open to new job opportunities, we can get you directly connected to our partner employers. If this job program is of interest to you, please submit your updated resume.”

The mail promised to share his resume with a few of Udacity’s partner companies, who included famous names like Google, Amazon and Facebook.

“I was like, ‘Really? You want to hire me?’” recalls Duberstein.

Though a little dubious, he put together a resume and sent it off. A few weeks later, a second letter arrived. It asked if he was interested in working as a programmer for a U.S. high-tech company.

“I was very surprised because I had no professional programming career at that time,” Duberstein says. The offer was a serious one, though, and after interviews in San Francisco totaling eight hours, he was told he had the job.

A similar tale played out 800 kilometers north of San Francisco, in Eugene, Oregon, where a 25-year-old man named Daniel Wilson used MOOCs to start a new career.

Until six months ago, Wilson was a mathematics teacher at a high school. On the side, he used a MOOC on programming and subsequently used this knowledge to find work as a software developer at a local company, called Concentric Sky.

“I had hardly written a line of code. I paid nothing and now here I am as a software developer,” he says.

He hopes MOOCs will help overthrow the existing U.S. educational system, which, he claims, is based on wealth and leaves graduates crippled with debt.

“Many of my friends are still paying back for their education,” he says.

Wayne Skipper is the 42-year-old founder of Concentric Sky and the man who hired Wilson.

“It is a very exciting moment,” Skipper says. “We can learn many things online without going to university.

“Everything changes rapidly, and the passion to keep learning new things is vital. Daniel has this passion and attitude,” he explains.

By RYUICHI KANARI/ The Asahi Shimbun Staff Writer
  • 1
submit to reddit
A café in New York hosts a study group for MOOC students. Members eventually become friends and some groups even go drinking after study. (Ryuichi Kanari)

A café in New York hosts a study group for MOOC students. Members eventually become friends and some groups even go drinking after study. (Ryuichi Kanari)

Toggle
  • A café in New York hosts a study group for MOOC students. Members eventually become friends and some groups even go drinking after study. (Ryuichi Kanari)
  • For an online course provided by edX, the professors explain the topic in the center while English subtitles are provided on the right. Each week’s theme is displayed on the left-hand side and students can watch them in order of preference. The photograph shows a course run by Harvard University professor Graham Allison, an expert in international politics. (The Asahi Shimbun GLOBE)

More AJW

Feature

Read More

REPRODUCTIVE MEDICINE

The world’s first baby conceived through in vitro fertilization was born 36 years ago in Britain, and reproductive medicine has assisted in the births of 5 million children around the world. How have such treatments contributed to society as the global population rises?

People

Read More

caption01_S

AKIRA HOSOMI: Railway consultant overcomes bike full of obstacles...

June 20, 2014

Working to change conventional wisdom in Vietnam, a Japanese railway consultant is looking to put the brakes on the swarms of motorbikes zipping through the streets of the nation’s cities and convince their riders to take...

Economy

Read More

caption01_S

Eurasia: As China’s rise reshapes continent, Japan has a...

January 10, 2014

The Japanese archipelago lies opposite Eurasia, a huge region now morphing into one integrated economic sphere. How should Japan deal with this New Continentalism?

Backstage

Read More

caption01_S

GAMARJOBAT: Japanese pantomime duo spreads laughter around the...

December 06, 2013

Editor’s Note: Gamarjobat, a wordless comedy double-act who perform around the world, will now appear in The Asahi Shimbun as our “silent supporters.” Their comedy videos, inspired by GLOBE feature stories, will be...